President Trump's Supporters: Good and Bad as Right and Wrong

Many of President Trump's supporters are ethics consequentialists. They believe that right actions are right because and only because they produce good results and wrong actions are wrong because and only because they produce bad results.

What do we mean by "good" and "bad?" For whom must these results be good? When should they be evaluated? Who should evaluate them? Should they be evaluated on a case-by-case basis or a policy-by-policy basis?
Different combinations of different answers to each of these five questions create a family of consequentialist ethics theories and not just one.
For many supporters of President Trump the answers are as follows: A good result is an outcome that is an improvement in overall wellbeing. These results must first be good for the United States and then, if possible, good for other nations too. They should be evaluated by the voters in the 2028 elections. They should be evaluated on a policy-by-policy basis.
There is a good chance that at Thanksgiving Dinner in 2028 these supporters of President Trump will praise God for his leadership.
Those who believe that considerations in addition to good or bad results make actions right or wrong-- such as treating others as we would consent to be treated even if this requires some sacrifice in our own overall wellbeing-- are less likely to be as thankful for President Trump's leadership.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Process Theology and Openness of God Theology: Necessarily, Essentially, Neither or Both: How Does God Love the World?

[This little paper contributed to a lasting differene in the dialogue between process theolgy and openness of of God theology. This difference has subsquently been most fully developed in Thomas J. Oord's "Essential Kenosis." DRL /20/2025] Process Theology and Openness of God Theology:  Necessarily, Essentially, Neither or Both:  How Does God Love the World? A Presentation by David R. Larson at the  November 2004 meetings of the American Academy of Religion  meetings in San Antonio, Texas “There is in God both supreme necessity and supreme contingency.” Karl Barth  God’s “conceptuality at once exemplifies  and establishes the categoreal conditions.”  Alfred North Whitehead  “God’s sociality cannot be satisfied by God’s self;   God’s love requires an object that is not God, namely, a world.”  Donna Bowman  [This little paper contributed to a lasting difference the dialogue between process theolgy and openness of of God...
Read more

Where the Adventist Society for Religious Studies and the Adventist Theological Society Most Differ and What We Should Do About It

More than  seven thousand religion scholars of all faiths and no faith at all convene each year at some city in the United States the weekend before the nation's Thanksgiving holiday for the joint annual meetings of the American Academy of Religion (AAR) and the Society of Biblical Literature (SBL).  They begin at noon on Saturday and continue through noon on Tuesday. The meetings of the AAR and SBL are usually integrated.They meet in the same hotels and convention centers.  Scholars may belong to either society or both.  They have the same schedules.  They print the sequence of their hundreds of sessions in the same thick 81/2 x 11 catalogue that also features many advertisements for new books and other things. When the catalogue is open, the times and places of the AAR sessions are often presented on the left page and those of the SBL are often presented on the right page.  Both societies host large plenary sessions in the evenings.  Even if they the...
Read more

Welcome!

There are many David Larsons in this world and even some David R. Larsons!  I am the only one who is Emeritus Professor of Religion at Loma Linda University.  Yes, my deceased parents were Ralph S. Larson and Jeanne Marjorie Riederer Larson. With this website, I start all over again.  I was with Typepad for many years but it went out of business.  I will gradually repost at this website some of things that I had posted at my previous one. There is a Search Box at the upper right hand corne the banner.  At the upper left hand corner, there are three small lines.  Clicking them takes one to the Archives and to the Labels clusters of posts that are similar in content.  For instance, there is a label for "Religion and Science."  There is only one post in this cluster but there will be more.  Also, at the bottom of each post there is an opportunity to make comments.  As evidenced by the fact that this is a .com website, I believe that I was t...
Read more